Focused Attention and Open Monitoring: Two Ways to Train the Mind

Introduction

Modern meditation research commonly distinguishes between two broad approaches to attention training. They are not competing schools or personality types — they are two different things you can do with your attention, and most long-term practitioners move between them.

Understanding the difference helps you pick a practice that matches what you need in a given moment, rather than treating "meditation" as one uniform activity.

Focused Attention: One Anchor, Many Returns

Focused attention (FA) practice means choosing a single anchor — commonly the breath — and placing your attention there. Sooner or later, the mind wanders. The core move of the practice is noticing that it wandered, and gently bringing it back.

Two things are being trained at once:

  • Noticing: the moment you realize you have drifted away from the anchor, you have done a repetition of self-awareness. In the research literature this catching of one's own wandering is closely related to meta-awareness.
  • Returning: re-directing attention without self-criticism trains a specific, repeatable act of regulation.

The wandering is not a failure of the exercise. Without wandering, there would be nothing to notice and no way to return — a session with many small returns is a session with many repetitions, not a bad session.

Examples on Kuakua: the immersion session (breathing preparation followed by quiet sitting) and the body scan both use an anchor — the breath, or a moving sequence of bodily regions.

Open Monitoring: Watching What Arises

Open monitoring (OM) practice starts — usually after some attention has settled — by opening the field of awareness. Instead of returning to one anchor, you observe whatever appears: sounds, bodily sensations, thoughts, moods. Nothing is pursued, nothing is pushed away.

Where FA narrows, OM widens. The skill being trained is the ability to remain a steady observer of experience without immediately reacting to it — the same stance that underlies urge surfing and other distancing skills.

A practical caveat: pure open monitoring is generally considered harder for beginners, because attention has fewer rails to run on. Most traditions treat some focused practice as a useful on-ramp.

How They Differ at a Glance

Focused attention Open monitoring
Attention goes to One chosen anchor Whatever arises
Wandering mind Notice and return Observe the wandering itself
Main skill trained Noticing and re-orienting Steady, non-reactive observation
Common entry point Beginners and restarts After some settling
Kuakua practice Immersion, body scan Quiet stillness with open awareness (prayer session), urge surfing

What the Evidence Does and Doesn't Say

Systematic reviews of meditation research do distinguish between these practice types, and studies link them to overlapping but not identical outcomes — for attention, emotion regulation, and wellbeing measures. Two honest caveats matter:

  1. Effects vary by outcome, population, and study design. Reviews repeatedly find heterogeneity; results from one style of study cannot be generalized to every self-guided practice.
  2. Neither style is "the effective one". Claims like "open monitoring makes you creative" or "focused attention fixes concentration" outrun the evidence. What is well supported is more modest: structured attention practice is a reasonable, low-risk way to practice noticing and regulating attention.

For the broader clinical picture of mindfulness-based approaches, see mindfulness-based therapy and the mindfulness overview.

How to Choose in a Given Moment

Rather than picking a school, pick based on your current state:

  • Thoughts very busy, hard to settle → start with focused attention; a short candid writing session before sitting can also discharge the noise.
  • Steady and curious → open monitoring or a quiet stillness session.
  • Tired → keep it short; a 1-minute immersion beats an ambitious session you will abandon.
  • Unsure → use the state chooser at the top of the practice page.

Common Misunderstandings

  • "Open monitoring means letting thoughts run wild." No — it means observing them without following them.
  • "Focused attention means suppressing thoughts." No — suppressing is another form of following. You notice, you return, you do not fight.
  • "One of them is the advanced form of the other." They train different, complementary skills; long-term practitioners typically use both.

Put It Into Practice

Last updated: 2026-10-20

Menu
Loading